God’s Commission to Kill the Midianites (Part 2)

The second response Torrey gives is:
  1. God’s command to wipe out the Canaanites/Midianites entirely was one of mercy and love. He then responds to questions related to the incident.
a)      What about the women? Could they not have been spared?
Ø  Women were the prime source of contamination among the people (Numbers 31: 15-16).
b)      What about the children?
Ø  Vices bred in ancestry over generations appears in the children. It was an act of mercy towards the children as their lives would have been far worse had they lived.

My View:
Firstly, how could a good God permit this holocaust? Torrey says that God in his kindness blotted out the Canaanites/Midianites through the Israelites. Can such an act be called kindness!? I think not. Is God partial towards other nations? The Old Testament may give us this impression.


Secondly, women are condemned as being the source of vice among the people. This is a simplistic statement. Isn’t sexual activity a two-way street? Are the women the only one’s to blame? Perhaps there were some women or many women who behaved in unbecoming fashion, but is that enough ground to order a wholesale massacre of all women who have slept with a man? Are people commodities to be done away with as one fancies? Therefore, the reason given by Torrey is insufficient and unacceptable. The same goes for the children. Whose right is it to decide whether the children ought to live or die? Or who can tell whether they will turn out to be as bad as or worse than the preceding generation? Is it not possible that they could choose otherwise and live God-fearing lives? Though there are many children who follow in their parents footsteps, there are so many more who discern what is good and choose to live by what is right. I don’t think that anyone can pass a metaphysical judgement on anyone else. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Great Grand Masti 2 (2016) (Movie Review)

Image
Dir: Indra Kumar Starring: Vivek Oberoi, Riteish Deshmukh, Aftab Shivdasani, Urvashi Rautela Dur: 2 hrs 10 mins Genre: Comedy Rating: 1/10 Comment: The jokes, gestures and costumes are sexually suggestive. An absolute waste of time. “What an opening line”, you might think. But to say otherwise would be an absolute lie. This film is in fact, a great grand waste of time. It’s horrible whichever way you look at it. The story is weak and thrives on cheap thrills and sorry jokes. The actresses are no doubt eye-catching but the rest is all a blur. The comedy is in fact tragedy and the film attempts to play on the basest desires of man. It’s unbelievable that actors like Riteish and Vivek would do such a film. I am not a big fan of bollywood but I still feel bad when I see bollywood making films like these. All of a sudden, I see that sex is being propagated through Indian cinema. The views of sex are changing and filmmakers and actors are not hesitating to take on unconvent
Read more

St. Joseph: A Father after the Father's Heart (Book Review)

Image
  St. Joseph: A Father after the Father’s Heart , Hyderabad: Don Bosco Publishing House, 2021, Rs. 150, pp. 240. The book is a compilation of articles from various authors writing about qualities of St. Joseph. They have used the litany of St. Joseph as an index and have put together articles on each of the invocations. All the contributors are Salesians from different parts of India but there a couple of contributors from abroad as well. The book lends itself to be a souvenir of the Year of St. Joseph that Pope Francis declared. Let me start out by commenting on the quality of production. The paper is of good quality and so is the design and layout. It is neat and has an attractive cover. Coming to the content, it gets rather repetitive but that is understandable considering that there is so little Biblical foundation for an exposition of St. Joseph. The articles often reference Pope Francis’ letter Patris Corde and extensively utilize Pope St. John Paul II’s apostolic exhortatio
Read more

A Day with Don Bosco

                              Don Bosco was declared the Patron of Youth by Pope John Paul II in 1989. He received his mission: to be Father to the young, in a dream at the tender age of nine. He nurtured this call throughout his life and never wasted an opportunity to gather boys and direct them to God. He did not do this as a spiritual director, (at least no at first!) but rather as a friend, a companion and a seminarian. As a young boy, he would attract youngsters with his magic tricks, tightrope skills, games etc and then get them to recite the rosary with him or recount to them the Sunday sermon (which he remembered thanks to his prodigious memory). Already then, he had ingeniously found a way to combine religion and entertainment. His entertainment was necer for entertainment sake but rather a façade or an advertisment for religious instruction. Even as a young priest, boys would long for more than just a wekkly encounter with him. They loved him and found in him a friend w
Read more